Claim Numbers Commercial Claim Numbers Claim NumbersNYCM1-888-234-6926Preferred Mutual1-800-333-7642Liberty Mutual1-800-522-7152Travelers1-800-252-4633Allstate1-800-255-7828Safeco1-877-566-6001Progressive1-800-274-4499Mercury1-800-503-3724National Grange Insurance / Main Street America1-877-425-2467Utica National1-800-216-1420Sterling1-800-462-4661Commercial Claim NumbersPreferred Mutual1-800-333-7642 prompt #4Liberty Mutual1-844-325-2467Utica National1-800-216-1420 24 HRSNational Grange Insurance / Main Street America1-877-425-2467Selective - Deforest1-866-455-9969 24 HRSTravelers1-800-832-7839Houston Casualty (HCC)1-800-225-6561 24 HRSMichigan Millers1-877-858-5361Erie & Niagara1-716-361-5461Leatherstocking1-800-886-8048 24 HRSEsip - McNeil1-800-822-3747 Prompt #9VFIS1-800-233-1957Madison Mutual1-800-688-3211 prompt #7Finger Lakes1-800-724-4032Eastern1-518-467-3871NYMIR1-800-894-9341
